ValkyaEditorial

Tagged “article-20”

3 articles on article-20.

Supreme CourtSupreme Court of India

CBI v. R.R. Kishore: Section 6A of the DSPE Act was void from birth, not from 2014

A five-judge Constitution Bench held that when the Court struck down Section 6A of the Delhi Special Police Establishment Act in Subramanian Swamy (2014), the provision was not merely invalid going forward — it was void ab initio, unenforceable from the date of its insertion on 11 September 2003. The Bench rejected the Article 20(1) ex-post-facto objection because Section 6A was a procedural protection, not a penal provision creating an offence.

Valkya Editorial··6 min
Supreme CourtSupreme Court of India

State of Tamil Nadu v. Ponnusamy: crime-scene re-enactment and Article 20(3)

On 19 May 2026, a two-judge bench held that a directed crime-scene re-enactment limited to physical movements does not per se amount to testimonial compulsion under Article 20(3); such material is admissible as corroborative — not substantive — evidence. Conviction restored on circumstantial proof; death sentence commuted to life.

Valkya Editorial··10 min